Sports Fountain’s NFL Top 10 After Week 9: Bills Claim No. 1, Broncos Make It 16 and Vikings Sink

Carson Wentz completed eight of 25 passes for 81 yards on Monday night, and the Buffalo Bills kept the ball for 42 minutes and 32 seconds of a 23-6 win in Minneapolis. The Minnesota Vikings, unbeaten a fortnight ago, have now scored 21 points in two games.
The rest of the week was busy in a different way. The Jacksonville Jaguars beat the Baltimore Ravens 33-10 on Thursday, then spent Monday trading five draft picks for three defenders. Caleb Williams threw four interceptions, and the Chicago Bears beat the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on the final play anyway. The Denver Broncos won another one-score game, a sentence I could now write most weeks. The Green Bay Packers put 45 points on the New England Patriots in Foxborough. The Detroit Lions beat the Miami Dolphins a week after Jack Campbell left Ford Field on a backboard. The San Francisco 49ers took the ball away five times in the second half against the Las Vegas Raiders. And C.J. Stroud threw five touchdown passes for the Houston Texans while, by his own account, feeling unwell. The Los Angeles Chargers are 0-8.
Our order reflects the season through Monday night, Nov. 9. The method is unchanged. The whole body of work counts, quality of opposition and control of games both matter, a loss is judged by where and how it happened, and last week’s position is held for no one. The arithmetic is new, though. Eight of these 10 teams now have two losses, so the loss column has stopped sorting anybody. Head-to-head results do more of the work this week, and so does the question I keep returning to: who have you actually beaten? To answer it properly, I added up the current records of every team each contender has beaten. Some of those totals are rather revealing.
Buffalo takes first. Jacksonville finally wins the argument I kept postponing. And Minnesota falls five places.
Editor's Picks
Sports Fountain Top 10 after Week 9, plus the rest of the league
| # | Team | Rec. | Prev. | Week 9 | Diff. | Strk. | Vs. top 10 | Week 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Buffalo Bills | 7-1 | 2 | W 23-6 at MIN | +69 | W4 | 2-0 | at NYJ |
| 2 | San Francisco 49ers | 7-1 | 1 | W 38-17 vs. LV | +79 | W1 | 1-0 | at DAL |
| 3 | Denver Broncos | 7-2 | 4 | W 26-21 at CAR | +12 | W5 | 2-2 | Bye |
| 4 | Jacksonville Jaguars | 6-2 | 6 | W 33-10 at BAL | +108 | W2 | 1-1 | at TEN |
| 5 | Chicago Bears | 7-2 | 5 | W 27-24 vs. TB | +57 | W4 | 0-1 | Bye |
| 6 | Pittsburgh Steelers | 6-2 | 7 | Bye | +36 | W4 | 1-0 | at CIN |
| 7 | Detroit Lions | 6-2 | 8 | W 19-9 at MIA | +33 | W4 | 1-1 | vs. NE (Munich) |
| 8 | Minnesota Vikings | 6-2 | 3 | L 23-6 vs. BUF | +30 | L2 | 1-2 | at GB |
| 9 | Kansas City Chiefs | 6-2 | 9 | W 35-12 vs. NYJ | +59 | W1 | 1-1 | at ATL |
| 10 | Cincinnati Bengals | 6-2 | 10 | W 34-17 at ATL (Madrid) | +65 | W4 | 0-2 | vs. PIT |
| NR | New York Giants | 5-2-1 | NR | W 19-11 at PHI | +10 | W2 | 0-0 | vs. WAS (Thu) |
| NR | Green Bay Packers | 6-3 | NR | W 45-27 at NE | +25 | W2 | 1-2 | vs. MIN |
| NR | Seattle Seahawks | 5-4 | NR | W 17-3 vs. ARI | +40 | W1 | 1-3 | at LV |
| NR | Los Angeles Rams | 5-4 | NR | W 20-13 at WAS | +33 | W3 | 0-3 | at ARI |
| NR | New England Patriots | 5-4 | NR | L 45-27 vs. GB | +4 | L1 | 2-2 | at DET (Munich) |
| NR | Cleveland Browns | 5-4 | NR | L 23-22 at NO (OT) | -35 | L2 | 1-2 | vs. HOU |
| NR | Dallas Cowboys | 4-5 | NR | W 27-23 at IND | +10 | W1 | 0-0 | vs. SF |
| NR | Las Vegas Raiders | 4-5 | NR | L 38-17 at SF | -30 | L1 | 0-3 | vs. SEA |
| NR | Baltimore Ravens | 4-5 | NR | L 33-10 vs. JAX | -47 | L4 | 0-3 | vs. LAC (Mon) |
| NR | Houston Texans | 3-5 | NR | W 44-22 at LAC | +17 | W1 | 1-2 | at CLE |
| NR | Carolina Panthers | 3-5 | NR | L 26-21 vs. DEN | -20 | L3 | 1-2 | at NO |
| NR | New Orleans Saints | 3-5 | NR | W 23-22 vs. CLE (OT) | -31 | W1 | 0-3 | vs. CAR |
| NR | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 3-6 | NR | L 27-24 at CHI | +24 | L1 | 0-4 | Bye |
| NR | Atlanta Falcons | 3-6 | NR | L 34-17 vs. CIN (Madrid) | -35 | L2 | 1-3 | vs. KC |
| NR | Arizona Cardinals | 3-6 | NR | L 17-3 at SEA | -77 | L1 | 0-3 | vs. LAR |
| NR | Washington Commanders | 2-5-1 | NR | L 20-13 vs. LAR | -30 | L1 | 0-1 | at NYG (Thu) |
| NR | New York Jets | 2-7 | NR | L 35-12 at KC | -41 | L4 | 0-3 | vs. BUF |
| NR | Indianapolis Colts | 2-7 | NR | L 27-23 vs. DAL | -65 | L5 | 0-4 | vs. MIA |
| NR | Philadelphia Eagles | 2-7 | NR | L 19-11 vs. NYG | -73 | L7 | 0-2 | Bye |
| NR | Tennessee Titans | 1-7 | NR | Bye | -55 | L2 | 0-1 | vs. JAX |
| NR | Miami Dolphins | 1-7 | NR | L 19-9 vs. DET | -74 | L2 | 0-5 | at IND |
| NR | Los Angeles Chargers | 0-8 | NR | L 44-22 vs. HOU | -98 | L8 | 0-3 | at BAL (Mon) |
NR = not ranked; unranked teams are listed by record, then point differential. Prev. = last week’s rank. Diff. = season point differential. Vs. top 10 = record against the 10 ranked teams. Week 10 games are Sunday, Nov. 15, unless marked Thu (Nov. 12) or Mon (Nov. 16).
1. Buffalo Bills (7-1)
Last week: 2 | Week 9: Beat the Minnesota Vikings 23-6
Last week I said a win in Minneapolis would move Buffalo up without much reluctance. There was very little reluctance involved.
The Bills did not need Josh Allen to be spectacular, which was fortunate on a night he was sacked four times. They needed James Cook, who carried 31 times for 107 yards, and a fourth-quarter drive of 15 plays and 8 minutes, 32 seconds that ended with his 5-yard touchdown. Allen finished 21-of-31 for 234 yards, and his best throw came on a scramble to his right with 44 seconds left in the half, when he found tight end Keleki Latu alone for a 25-yard score, the first of Latu’s career. Buffalo did all of this without its starting left tackle, Dion Dawkins, or its starting left guard, Alec Anderson.
“Eventually you end up making it a game that they weren’t willing to play,” Joe Brady said.
Now, about the defense. I was slow to praise it last week, and I am only marginally quicker now. Minnesota finished with 178 yards, went 0-for-7 on third down and turned it over three times, with Terrel Bernard and Dorian Williams each intercepting Wentz. Over two weeks, Buffalo has allowed 16 points. The quarterbacks responsible were an undrafted rookie making his NFL debut and a 33-year-old backup who completed eight passes. The footnote stays, but it is getting smaller.
Why Buffalo over San Francisco, when both are 7-1? The Bills have beaten two teams that are 6-2, Detroit and Minnesota, the second of them on the road. San Francisco’s best win, over Denver, is as good as either, but it is one win to Buffalo’s two. The Bills’ only loss came by three points to a New England team with a winning record, and San Francisco’s came by nine against the Atlanta Falcons, who are 3-6. The 49ers still have the better defense, by 31 points so far. That gap no longer outweighs the rest.
The Bills visit the New York Jets on Sunday. The Jets kicked four field goals in the first half against the Kansas City Chiefs and lost by 23, which may tell Buffalo most of what it needs to know.
2. San Francisco 49ers (7-1)
Last week: 1 | Week 9: Beat the Las Vegas Raiders 38-17
The 49ers moved up a place last week by not playing. This week they won by 21 and moved down one, which I accept is not a system designed for their peace of mind.
The halftime score was 21-10, and the second half belonged to the defense. Jaden Dugger returned a Kirk Cousins interception 35 yards for a touchdown on the first play after the break, and San Francisco finished the half with five takeaways, its first such game since doing it to the Raiders at Candlestick Park 20 years ago. Las Vegas has now allowed at least 30 points in six straight games, which ties an NFL record nobody wants.
“That was honestly the emphasis going into the week. To come out the second half and have five of those was unbelievable,” Fred Warner said.
Brock Purdy threw two touchdown passes and ran for a third, and he became the 10th quarterback since the merger to reach 100 touchdown passes in his first 57 career games. The cost was considerable, though. Rookie defensive tackle Gracen Halton broke his left ankle and is expected to miss the rest of the season, and cornerbacks Renardo Green and Deommodore Lenoir both left hurt. The 49ers also played without Mike Evans, who is out with Achilles tendinitis.
San Francisco stays above Denver because it beat the Broncos 24-14 in October. Second place is not much of a demotion for a team that has lost once.
The 49ers visit the Dallas Cowboys on Sunday, a team that has blown fourth-quarter leads in each of its last two games. San Francisco would ideally avoid testing whether the habit holds.
3. Denver Broncos (7-2)
Last week: 4 | Week 9: Beat the Carolina Panthers 26-21
Sixteen, then.
Last week I called Denver’s run of one-score wins either a remarkable skill or the longest coincidence in football. The Broncos have now won 16 straight games decided by eight points or fewer, and their coach has picked a side.
“When those things keep falling your way, that’s not by accident,” Sean Payton said.
Sunday offered evidence for both views. Carolina led 14-13 at halftime and had first-and-goal at the Denver 1 late in the third quarter, when officials ruled that Payton had thrown his challenge flag before the snap. The review gave Devon Key an interception on the previous play, and the Panthers’ touchdown chance went with it.
“I’ve never seen someone run a play full through and then get a challenge for a previous play,” Panthers tight end Tommy Tremble said.
Denver then drove 80 yards in 14 plays for Jonah Coleman’s 9-yard touchdown run, Bo Nix found Pat Bryant for 25 yards and another score, and Nik Bonitto ended Carolina’s last drive with a strip-sack he recovered himself. It was the Broncos’ fifth fourth-quarter comeback, tying the 2016 Lions and 2022 Vikings for the most by any team through nine games since 2000.
The discomfort has not gone anywhere. Denver is plus-12, still the smallest margin in this top 10 by 18 points, and Jaylen Waddle and Riley Moss both left with concussions. But four of Denver’s seven wins came against teams with winning records, including the Seattle Seahawks, the Los Angeles Rams, Kansas City and Jacksonville, and nobody else in this top 10 has more than three. The 20-13 win over the Jaguars in September keeps Denver above them. The 24-14 loss in Santa Clara keeps it below San Francisco.
The bye arrives at a sensible moment. Nobody needs another one-score game this week, least of all the people in Denver who have been watching them.
4. Jacksonville Jaguars (6-2)
Last week: 6 | Week 9: Beat the Baltimore Ravens 33-10
Last week I said losing nose tackle DaVon Hamilton was the part of Jacksonville’s season that should worry them. James Gladstone appears to have been worried as well.
On Monday, the Jaguars’ general manager traded for safety Jessie Bates III from Atlanta, defensive tackle Davon Godchaux from the New Orleans Saints and defensive tackle Jordan Davis from the Philadelphia Eagles. It cost five draft picks, including a first-rounder and two seconds, and Davis alone accounted for a 2027 first and a 2029 second. Gladstone has looked at the AFC, decided it is there to be won and paid accordingly.
Thursday asked very little of anyone. Jacksonville opened with a 77-yard touchdown drive, Trevor Lawrence threw a 50-yard touchdown to Parker Washington before halftime, and Joe Fagnano finished 10-of-18 for 60 yards with two interceptions. Baltimore has now lost three straight games by at least 20 points for the first time in franchise history. I will not grade the defense on this one, for the same reason I would not grade Buffalo’s on the same opponent a week earlier.
So here is the argument I promised to have ready by Friday, delivered rather late. Jacksonville and Chicago now have the same number of losses. The Jaguars have beaten three teams with winning records to the Bears’ two, including the Cincinnati Bengals on the road. Their six victims are a combined 24-29, and Chicago’s seven are 23-39. Their plus-108 margin leads the league by 29 points. Chicago’s losses, to Minnesota and Green Bay, are better than Jacksonville’s to Houston, and that kept the Bears ahead for a fortnight. After a week in which the Jaguars won by 23 and the Bears needed the final snap against a 3-6 team, it no longer does.
Jacksonville visits the Tennessee Titans on Sunday, which should give the new arrivals a gentle introduction. Tennessee is 1-7.
5. Chicago Bears (7-2)
Last week: 5 | Week 9: Beat the Tampa Bay Buccaneers 27-24
Caleb Williams completed six of his first eight passes for 105 yards and two touchdowns. Over the rest of the night he threw four interceptions, a career high, and Chicago won anyway.
The Bears led 14-0 after a quarter, with Rome Odunze and Luther Burden III scoring, and then Tampa Bay started coming after Williams. The Buccaneers blitzed him on 26 of 41 dropbacks, and after that first quarter he went 16-of-29 for 174 yards with no touchdowns and a passer rating of 33.5. Chicago turned it over five times. Jaylon Johnson’s 67-yard interception return made it 24-13, Burden then fumbled after a helmet-to-helmet hit, and Baker Mayfield’s two-point run tied it at 24 with 2:51 left. Williams found Colston Loveland for 38 yards on the next drive, and Cairo Santos kicked a 38-yard field goal as time expired.
“I don’t get gun shy. That’s not me. That’s not my identity. And with that, I’m going to keep ripping it and keep ripping it,” Williams said.
Nobody who watched the fourth quarter doubted it. Jeffery Simmons added a sack, which makes two useful games from two since the trade, and Burden left with a concussion.
The Bears’ seven wins have come against teams with a combined 23-39 record, the softest collection among my top five, and that is why Jacksonville passes them. Chicago stays ahead of the Pittsburgh Steelers because it has one more win and its two losses came against Minnesota and Green Bay, both of them winning teams. Yes, Minnesota beat the Bears. I deal with that further down.
Chicago’s bye arrives this week. I imagine the film session on the blitzes will be a long one.

6. Pittsburgh Steelers (6-2)
Last week: 7 | Week 9: Bye
For the second week running, a team on its bye moves up a place, and Pittsburgh can thank Minnesota, as San Francisco did.
The weekend was kinder to the Steelers’ ranking than to their resume. Both teams that have beaten them lost on Sunday, and neither lost in a way that flatters Pittsburgh. New England allowed 45 points, the most it has ever conceded at Gillette Stadium, and the Cleveland Browns lost in overtime to a New Orleans team that is now 3-5. The 20-3 defeat in Foxborough was never pretty. It looks slightly worse now.
What Pittsburgh does have is a defense. The Steelers have allowed 144 points in eight games, and they have won four straight since that loss in Cleveland. Their best win, 30-27 over Cincinnati in Week 3, is about as good as Detroit’s best, and the 45-point gap in points allowed between the two teams is the tiebreak I keep coming back to.
The Steelers visit Cincinnati on Sunday night with the AFC North lead shared between them at 6-2. A second win over the Bengals would give Pittsburgh the sweep and, with it, the first tiebreaker in the division.
7. Detroit Lions (6-2)
Last week: 8 | Week 9: Beat the Miami Dolphins 19-9
“The whole week was prepare and play like Jack. Kind of felt like we owed it to him. It’s all we can do,” Dan Campbell said.
Jack Campbell went on injured reserve with his neck injury this week, and the Lions won without him in a game that was not elegant. Jared Goff threw for a season-low 170 yards, took three sacks and threw only his second interception of the season. Jahmyr Gibbs needed 20 carries for 74 yards, though his fourth-down touchdown run in the third quarter was the 60th of his career, level with LaDainian Tomlinson for the second-most by any player through four seasons. Jake Bates kicked four field goals, punter Jack Fox threw for a first down on a fake, and Aidan Hutchinson had six pressures in 16 one-on-one matchups with Austin Jackson. Miami went 0-for-3 in the red zone.
Detroit sits above Minnesota because the records now match and the Lions won the meeting 19-15 in Week 8. It sits below Pittsburgh by the width of a defense. The Steelers have allowed 45 fewer points, and the Lions’ loss to the Carolina Panthers remains the worst defeat either team owns.
The Lions play the Patriots in Munich on Sunday. Kickoff is 9:30 a.m. ET, which should at least leave the afternoon free for watching Minnesota.
8. Minnesota Vikings (6-2)
Last week: 3 | Week 9: Lost to the Buffalo Bills 23-6
Last week I said the number to worry about was 23, the most Minnesota had scored in any game since Week 1. On Monday night, the number was six.
With Kyler Murray out with a hamstring strain, Wentz went 8-of-25 for 81 yards with three turnovers, one of them a backward pass to Justin Jefferson that sailed high and became a lost fumble. He went 1-of-8 in the second half before Max Brosmer replaced him. Minnesota had the ball for 17 minutes, 28 seconds, and Jefferson caught three of the 11 passes thrown his way.
“Put tonight 100% on me. It’s not about any one particular player,” Kevin O’Connell said.
The defense deserves rather better. Minnesota has allowed 116 points in eight games, and Buffalo, the highest-scoring team in the league, needed 31 carries from Cook and three field goals to reach 23. Murray is week to week.
Third to eighth is a steep fall for two losses to teams in my top seven, so here is the reasoning. Detroit has the same record and beat Minnesota, so the Lions go above. Chicago is the harder case, because the Vikings beat the Bears 9-3 in September, and if this were purely a head-to-head exercise they would sit above them. It is not. Chicago has one more win, has gone 6-1 since then, and is averaging 26.8 points a game to Minnesota’s 18.3. Head-to-head breaks a tie, and this stopped being one. Pittsburgh and Jacksonville have never played Minnesota, and both have done more lately by every measure I can find.
The Vikings stay above Kansas City and Cincinnati for the reason that runs through this whole list. Minnesota’s six victims, Green Bay and Chicago among them, are a combined 22-30. Kansas City’s are 16-36. That gap still outweighs a bad fortnight, for now.
Minnesota visits Green Bay on Sunday. The Packers have scored 72 points in their last two games and lost to the Vikings by 17 in Week 1, so I expect they remember it.
9. Kansas City Chiefs (6-2)
Last week: 9 | Week 9: Beat the New York Jets 35-12
Patrick Mahomes is now 18-0 against teams that arrive four or more games under .500, the best record by any quarterback since 1970 with at least 15 such starts. Sunday was the 18th, and it went the way the first 17 presumably did.
Kenneth Walker III scored three times, twice on short passes, and finished with 143 yards from scrimmage. Mahomes went 23-of-31 for 242 yards and two touchdowns. Chris Jones and George Karlaftis had two sacks each, and the Jets scored all 12 of their points on field goals before halftime. The worry came when a strip-sack bent Mahomes’ right arm badly. He returned, and he is due for more tests on the elbow.
Harrison Butker also missed from 56 and 51 yards. Last week I called 1-of-6 from 50 yards a fairly generous definition of range, and Andy Reid had heard enough of the subject.
The ranking holds for the reason I gave last week. Beyond the 31-10 win over Denver, Kansas City’s victims are the Indianapolis Colts, Miami, Las Vegas, the Chargers and the Jets. With Denver included, they are a combined 16-36. That puts the Chiefs behind Minnesota. The Denver win, which is one more win over a winning team than Cincinnati has, keeps them ahead of the Bengals.
Kansas City visits Atlanta on Sunday. The Falcons beat San Francisco in Week 7 and have lost twice since.
10. Cincinnati Bengals (6-2)
Last week: 10 | Week 9: Beat the Atlanta Falcons 34-17 in Madrid
Joe Burrow completed 24 of 29 passes in Madrid, and Ja’Marr Chase had 142 receiving yards by halftime.
“I wanted to come out and put on a show for everybody and show what the excitement of the NFL can be,” Burrow said.
He did, more or less. Cincinnati scored on every first-half possession and has now put up at least 30 points in four straight games. Burrow threw three touchdown passes and ran for another, Chase finished with 10 catches for 155 yards, and Tee Higgins caught two touchdowns. When Atlanta failed to pressure him, Burrow went 20-of-23.
In one respect this is the same entry as last week. Cincinnati still has not beaten a team with a winning record, and its six victims are now a combined 15-36, the softest list in this top 10. Green Bay has the better wins. Cincinnati has one fewer loss, though, and both of its defeats came against teams on this list by a combined eight points. That keeps the Bengals in, narrowly, for another week.
Pittsburgh visits on Sunday night. If I had set out to design a game to answer the question I keep asking about Cincinnati, I could not have done much better.
Just outside
Green Bay Packers (6-3): Last week I said the trip to Foxborough might settle both this entry and New England’s. It settled New England’s, at least. Jordan Love went 23-of-29 for 372 yards and three touchdowns, ran for another and now leads the league with 2,618 passing yards. Christian Watson (171 yards) and Matthew Golden (164) became the first Packers teammates to top 150 receiving yards with a touchdown catch apiece in the same game since Don Hutson and Andy Uram in 1942. Josh Jacobs broke a finger. Green Bay has won five of six, and its six victims are a combined 24-29, far better than Cincinnati’s 15-36. The third loss, 35-14 at home to Atlanta, is what keeps the Packers out. Minnesota visits Sunday.
New York Giants (5-2-1): The Giants won in Philadelphia for the first time since Oct. 27, 2013, ending a run of 13 straight Eagles home wins in the series, playoffs included. They lead the NFC East and have the same number of losses as most of my top 10. They have also beaten nobody with a winning record, their five victims are a combined 13-30, and they lost at home to New Orleans. J.J. McCarthy hurt his hip and came back. The Washington Commanders visit Thursday night.
New England Patriots (5-4): Last week’s hardest call has been taken out of my hands. Drake Maye threw three first-half interceptions, and Green Bay never trailed. The Patriots still own wins at Buffalo and over Pittsburgh. They also now own four losses. Detroit in Munich comes next.
Read last week’s Week 8 ranking.














Join the discussion
Be the first to join this discussion
Be respectful toward authors and fellow readers.
Sign in or create an account to join the conversation.
Report comment
Tell the moderation team why this comment may break the community guidelines.