Jerry Jones, Peyton Manning and “Seeing Ghosts”: 10 NFL Claims Checked After Week 9

Three weeks ago, the Indianapolis Colts’ owner fired her general manager and said the move did not change the team’s goals for the season. The Colts have not won since.
That is the kind of claim this week is built on. Two owners, a league office, two coaches, two players and three of the loudest voices in sports media all said something big about the NFL in the last few weeks, and most of it had nothing to do with a single throw or tackle. Every week, Sports Fountain takes 10 of the biggest claims around the league, checks them against what we actually know and tells you where we stand. These are Week 9’s.
1. Carlie Irsay-Gordon, Colts owner: Firing Chris Ballard “does not change our goals for the season”
Irsay-Gordon fired Ballard on Oct. 19, the morning after a home loss to a Tennessee Titans team that had not won all season. She said waiting until January would only delay work that needed to start immediately, and then she made a promise about the rest of 2026.
Editor's Picks
“I also want to be clear: this decision does not change our goals for the season. We have a lot of football in front of us, and I expect us to compete, improve, and win football games,” Irsay-Gordon said.
The Colts were 2-4 that morning. They are 2-7 now, with five straight losses. They have competed, to be fair. They led the Dallas Cowboys in the fourth quarter on Sunday before losing 27-23, but they were outgained by 237 yards, and Daniel Jones threw for 180.
Where we stand: Disagree. Owners are supposed to say this, and it was the right thing to tell a locker room. But the goals changed the moment the general manager left in October, whatever the statement said. A 2-7 team’s real work now is the GM hire, the quarterback question and what to do with Shane Steichen. Winning football games in November would be nice. It is no longer the point.
2. Dan Patrick, The Dan Patrick Show: The Colts’ first call is Peyton Manning
Patrick put it out on Oct. 19, hours after Ballard was fired. His show posted that the Colts’ first call “will be/has been” to Manning.
“The Colts’ first call will be/has been to Peyton Manning.” — DP shares what his source has told him. https://t.co/MgTbuJIxhW
— Dan Patrick Show (@dpshow) October 19, 2026
Six days later, ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported the opposite. The Colts had not approached Manning about the job, and his sources said Manning was not expected to be interested, largely because running a front office would collide with Omaha Productions and the ManningCast. Schefter left one door open: Manning would listen to the right NFL opportunity at any time, and the examples floated were a Tom Brady-style ownership stake or a Matt Ryan-style president’s role.
Indianapolis named Ed Dodds interim general manager instead.
Where we stand: Disagree. Patrick hedged with “will be/has been,” and the name was not a crazy one for a franchise looking for a reset. The job was the wrong one. Manning does not need a GM chair at 50, and the Colts do not need a search built around a man who is not in it. If Manning ever comes back to Indianapolis, it will be above the GM, not in his place.
3. Jerry Jones, Cowboys owner: Brian Schottenheimer’s job is safe, and the collapse is “an indictment of the whole show”
Jones said it on Nov. 1, after Dallas blew a 14-point fourth-quarter lead and lost 33-30 in overtime to the Arizona Cardinals. The Cowboys did not trail until the game ended.
“Again we’re not going to get into anything, that’s not in my mind at this time. This is an indictment of the whole show. This is a criticism of everyone,” Jones said. He also said a lot of people let Schottenheimer down that day.
Cowboys owner Jerry Jones: “This is an indictment of the whole show … This is a criticism of everyone.”
On making a change on the coaching staff:
“That’s not in my mind at this time.”
— Nick Harris (@NickHarrisFWST) November 1, 2026
The whole show performed again on Sunday. Dallas beat the Colts 27-23 but committed 14 penalties for 153 yards, blew a fourth-quarter lead for the second straight week and needed a touchdown with 68 seconds left to win a game in which it outgained Indianapolis 508-271. Linebacker DeMarvion Overshown, who was inactive, drew a flag by running onto the field to celebrate a takeaway.
Colin Cowherd’s verdict the next day was that the Cowboys do have a culture, just “a circus” of one.
“The Cowboys have a culture. It’s just one that lacks responsibility or details… It’s just a circus.”
@colincowherd on DeMarvion Overshown’s embarrassing penalty vs. the Colts https://t.co/PSPErq8Lsb
— Herd w/Colin Cowherd (@TheHerd) November 9, 2026
Where we stand: Agree, on both halves. Firing a coach at 3-5 rarely fixes anything, and Schottenheimer did not commit 14 penalties himself. The indictment line is the more honest part, and Jones should hear it in full. The whole show includes the general manager, and in Dallas the general manager is the owner. At 4-5, the Cowboys’ problem is the structure Jones built around the coach, and that structure is the one thing nobody in Frisco can fire.
4. Nick Wright, FS1’s First Things First: Nick Sirianni won’t survive this season, and Shane Steichen will replace him
“I think Shane Steichen will be the next head coach of the Philadelphia Eagles. I said it a week ago. I’ll say it again. I don’t think Sirianni is going to survive this type of season,” Wright said on Oct. 27. He also said the Eagles should hold a fire sale.
“You hold a fire sale and I think you start getting your search committee ready for a head coach. I think that’s what they’re going to do… I don’t think Sirianni is going to survive this type of season.”
@getnickwright thinks Shane Steichen will be the next Eagles HC: https://t.co/XxXKbI4UGc
— First Things First (@FTFonFS1) October 27, 2026
Two weeks later, the fire sale has started. Philadelphia traded defensive tackle Jordan Davis to the Jacksonville Jaguars on Monday, a day after a 19-11 home loss to the New York Giants left the Eagles 2-7 for the first time since 1999. They have lost seven straight.
Sirianni has not budged on his staff.
“Everything can always be on the table, but I don’t think you change just to change because that’s what your record says. You’ve got to look at what’s really real and not react to anything else,” Sirianni said.
Where we stand: Too early on Sirianni, but the ground has moved. In Week 7 we said nothing from ownership pointed to a firing, and that is still true. A team that trades a 26-year-old defensive tackle for picks is planning for a different 2027, though, and coaches rarely survive those plans unchanged. The Steichen half is shakier. As claim No. 1 shows, his own seat in Indianapolis is hot enough that he may well be available. Whether Philadelphia wants a coach who is 2-7 elsewhere is another matter.
5. Seth Walder, ESPN: The Jordan Davis trade is a disaster for Jacksonville
Walder gave the Jaguars an F for sending a 2027 first-round pick and a 2029 second-round pick to Philadelphia for Davis.
“There’s no other way to start this: This trade is a disaster for Jacksonville,” Walder wrote.
His argument is about price. Davis was one of three defenders Jacksonville added on Monday, along with safety Jessie Bates III and defensive tackle Davon Godchaux, and the Jaguars gave up five picks in all. They made the moves after losing nose tackle DaVon Hamilton for the season.
The case for the buyer sits in Walder’s own article. Entering Monday, ESPN’s Football Power Index gave the Jaguars a 12.8% chance to win the Super Bowl, the best in the AFC.
Where we stand: Agree on the price, disagree on the word. A disaster is a trade that costs you the season or the future. This one costs Jacksonville a pick that, if things go to plan, lands near the end of the 2027 first round, and it was made by a 6-2 team with a 3 1/2-game division lead and a real chance to win it all. Expensive, yes. A disaster only if Davis plays like a rotation player in January.
6. Alan Butterworth, NFL vice president of instant replay: Replay can check whether a challenge flag came before the snap
The Denver Broncos’ 26-21 win in Carolina turned on a play that was ruled incomplete, followed by a snap, followed by a reversal.
With 1:30 left in the third quarter and the Carolina Panthers leading 14-13 at the Denver 1, Bryce Young’s pass bounced off tight end Tommy Tremble’s forearm, and safety Devon Key caught it just off the grass. The officials ruled it incomplete, and Carolina ran another play. Sean Payton’s flag, it turned out, was already in the air. The interception stood, and Denver took over at its own 20 and scored on a 14-play drive.
“Replay can get involved to make sure that the head coach throws his challenge flag prior to the next snap,” Butterworth said in a pool report. “We were actually able to use angles to show that the flag was out prior to the ball being snapped,” he added.
The win was Denver’s 16th straight in a one-score game, an NFL record.
Where we stand: Agree. The alternative is worse. If an offense could erase a legal challenge simply by snapping the ball while the flag was in the air, every team facing a close call would hurry to the line, which is exactly what the challenge system is supposed to stop. Payton did his job, and the replay office checked the one thing that mattered. The league’s only mistake is that most fans learned this rule existed on Sunday afternoon.
7. Quentin Lake, Rams safety, on the St. Brown Podcast: Justin Herbert is “seeing ghosts”
Lake intercepted Herbert in the Los Angeles Rams’ 24-9 win over the Los Angeles Chargers in Week 8, and he did not hold back afterward.
“I mean he was throwing deli meat out there. He’s seeing ghosts,” Lake said on the podcast hosted by Amon-Ra and Equanimeous St. Brown.
Jim Harbaugh rejected that. “It’s not what I see,” Harbaugh said. Days earlier, he had given a one-word answer when asked whether he had considered benching his quarterback.
Sunday made the argument for both of them. The Houston Texans beat the Chargers 44-22 and sacked Herbert eight times, with Sheldon Rankins, Jadeveon Clowney and Will Anderson Jr. getting two each. Herbert went 13-of-23 for 193 yards with a touchdown and an interception before leaving with a glove on his non-throwing hand. Mike McDaniel called plays from the booth for the first time since 2021. It did not help. The Chargers are 0-8.
Where we stand: Half right, on both sides. Lake described what he saw, and Herbert entered Sunday leading the league in interceptions and ranked last in QBR. But a quarterback who is hit like Herbert was on Sunday, behind a mostly rookie offensive line, will see ghosts because real ones keep arriving. Harbaugh is right not to bench him. He is wrong if he thinks the tape looks fine.
8. Kevin O’Connell, Vikings coach: Monday’s loss is “100% on me”
Stephen A. Smith said on First Take that a Carson Wentz performance close to Josh Allen’s would make Wentz the Minnesota Vikings’ starter. The test was not close. Wentz went 8-of-25 for 81 yards with three turnovers against the Buffalo Bills, completed one pass in the second half and was replaced by Max Brosmer in the fourth quarter of a 23-6 loss.
“If Wentz wins this game, … [he] is gonna be the new starting quarterback for the Minnesota Vikings.”
—@stephenasmith on what’s on the line for Carson Wentz facing the Buffalo Bills 👀 https://t.co/hw31mHXJTn
— First Take (@FirstTake) November 6, 2026
O’Connell took the blame himself.
“Put tonight 100% on me. It’s not about any one particular player,” O’Connell said.
The numbers behind the quote go back further than one night. By the Associated Press’ count before kickoff, the Vikings had switched starting quarterbacks 17 times in 52 games since Kirk Cousins tore his Achilles in October 2023, including five in-game changes. Brosmer’s entrance on Monday added another. Kyler Murray is out with a hamstring strain, and the hope is that he returns for Sunday’s trip to Green Bay.
Where we stand: Agree, and it reaches further than he meant. Minnesota has scored 21 points in two straight losses, and that is on the play-caller. Seventeen changes in three seasons is on the building around him, which has never settled who the quarterback is. A 6-2 team with this defense should not be one hamstring away from 8-of-25.
9. Caleb Williams, Bears quarterback: “I’m going to keep ripping it”
Williams threw a career-high four interceptions against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Sunday night, and the Chicago Bears turned the ball over five times. They won anyway, 27-24, when Cairo Santos made a 38-yard field goal as time expired after Williams found Colston Loveland for 38 yards.
He made no apology for the approach.
“I don’t get gun shy. That’s not me. That’s not my identity. And with that, I’m going to keep ripping it and keep ripping it,” Williams said.
Ben Johnson was more measured. “It’s hard to win with five turnovers and yet we found a way to do it,” the Bears coach said.
Williams finished 22-of-37 for 279 yards and two touchdowns, and Tampa Bay blitzed him on 26 of 41 dropbacks. A week earlier, Cowherd had called Chicago the best team in football. We added up the current records of the seven teams the Bears have beaten. They are a combined 23-39.
Where we stand: Agree with the mindset, not the math. Williams’ willingness to throw into tight windows is a big reason the Bears are 7-2, and a quarterback who flinches after four picks is worse than one who does not. But “keep ripping it” against a defense blitzing on nearly two of every three dropbacks is how a 3-6 team almost beat you. The best quarterbacks keep the aggression and lose the turnovers. Williams has the first part.
10. Dan Orlovsky, ESPN’s Get Up: Give me the Packers over the Vikings
Orlovsky said it on Oct. 30, with Minnesota still unbeaten and the Green Bay Packers two games behind.
“Give me the Packers over the Vikings. I agree, the defense is unbelievable. Their offense is not good. They don’t get open, the quarterback is not hitting [open] people. They can’t run the football either,” Orlovsky said.
“I might make the argument the Packers are still the fourth team in their own division.” 😱
@PSchrags and @danorlovsky7 debate on where Green Bay stands after their victory against the Panthers on TNF. https://t.co/TlRXsiugKj
— Get Up (@GetUpESPN) October 30, 2026
Since then, Green Bay has scored 45 points in one game, a win in Foxborough over the New England Patriots. Minnesota has scored 21 points in two games, both losses.
The Vikings still have the better record at 6-2 to 6-3, and they beat Green Bay by 17 in Week 1.
Where we stand: Agree. Minnesota’s defense is real, and it was real when Orlovsky said this. The offense he described is the one that showed up in Detroit and again on Monday. The two teams meet at Lambeau Field on Sunday, which is about as tidy a test as a claim ever gets.
Checking back on Week 7
Jacob Infante, Pro Football Network: The Vikings could be the most fraudulent 6-0 team ever. We called them lopsided, not frauds. They have since scored 21 points in two losses. We still would not use Infante’s word for a team with wins over Green Bay and Chicago, but lopsided is starting to sound generous.
Adam Schefter, ESPN: The Giants can win the NFC East with J.J. McCarthy. They lead it at 5-2-1 after winning in Philadelphia for the first time since 2013. McCarthy hurt his hip on Sunday and came back. So far, so good.
Rob Gronkowski, The Gronk and Jules Show: No reason to panic about the 49ers. They are 7-1. Nobody panicked.
Scott Petrak, BrownsZone: The Browns are a wild-card team, and the division is on the table. Cleveland has lost two straight and is 5-4, a game and a half behind both Pittsburgh and Cincinnati. The wild card is still realistic. The division has moved further away.
Ben Solak, ESPN: The Colts should give Anthony Richardson Sr. a chance. Indianapolis has lost five straight and is 2-7, and Daniel Jones threw for 180 yards against Dallas. With the owner’s goals now pointed at next year, Solak’s case has only grown.
Sunday at Lambeau Field should settle claim No. 10 and say plenty about No. 8. We will be back with the results, and 10 new claims, next week.
















Join the discussion
Be the first to join this discussion
Be respectful toward authors and fellow readers.
Sign in or create an account to join the conversation.
Report comment
Tell the moderation team why this comment may break the community guidelines.