Sports Fountain’s College Football Week 9: 10 Claims, Where We Stand

A week ago, Paul Finebaum said a loss to the Ohio State Buckeyes and a backup quarterback would finish Lincoln Riley. On Saturday night, in the rain at the Coliseum, the USC Trojans beat Ohio State 30-18, and Riley woke up on Sunday still very much employed.
That was one of several confident things said about college football this week by people with very firm opinions. Saturday tested most of them. A few held up nicely. Others could use a quiet word.
This is the first edition of a weekly Sunday series. Every week, Sports Fountain will take 10 of the biggest college football claims from the people paid to make them, check them against what actually happened and tell you where we stand. These are Week 9’s.

Editor's Picks
1. Paul Finebaum, ESPN: A loss to Ohio State will finish Lincoln Riley
Finebaum made the call on The Matt Barrie Show on Oct. 25, the day after USC scored seven points in a 24-7 loss to the Wisconsin Badgers. He described the Halloween game as the biggest of Riley’s career, then went further.
“A loss to Ohio State and a backup quarterback will finish him,” Finebaum said.
The loss never came. Jayden Maiava hit Trent Mosley for a 69-yard touchdown on USC’s second snap, finished 15 of 22 for 222 yards, and the Trojans led by 18 in the third quarter.
Before Saturday, only the Texas Longhorns had scored more than 19 points on Ohio State’s defense this season. USC scored 30, and the Buckeyes did not find the end zone until 2:12 remained, on a Luke Fahey pass to Jeremiah Smith that gave Smith the Big Ten record for career touchdown catches.
Where we stand: The condition Finebaum set never arrived, the win did not save Riley. USC is 7-2 with a bye, a trip to the Indiana Hoosiers on Nov. 14 and a finale at the UCLA Bruins still ahead. I would describe Riley’s job as rescued for a fortnight rather than secured.
2. Trey Wallace, OutKick: Ohio State has not earned a top-12 spot in Tuesday’s first CFP rankings
Writing in the early hours of Sunday, Wallace argued that nothing about the performance at USC should persuade the selection committee to put Ohio State “in the top-12” when the first rankings are released on Tuesday night.
The trouble is that the committee does not rank one performance. Ohio State is 6-2, and both losses came on the road: by a point at Texas in September and by 12 at USC with a true freshman making his first start. The Buckeyes also own a 19-15 win in Bloomington that ended Indiana’s 22-game winning streak, plus a win over the Iowa Hawkeyes, of course Ohio State is still a playoff team.
Where we stand: Disagree on the rankings. A team that won at Indiana and lost by one at Texas is a top-12 team on paper, and it seems paper is what the committee claims to read. Wallace is on firmer ground with his larger point, that this does not look like a title team without Julian Sayin. The Oregon Ducks visit Columbus on Saturday, which is a convenient time to find out.
3. Urban Meyer, Big Noon Kickoff: UCLA and Ohio State will meet in the Big Ten Championship Game
Meyer made his pick from Iowa City on Saturday morning, hours before Ohio State kicked off in Los Angeles.
“I’m saying UCLA against Ohio State in the Big Ten Championship Game,” Meyer said.
Ohio State and WHO in the Big Ten Championship?
@CoachUrbanMeyer https://t.co/HiCQdsT56F
— Big Noon Kickoff (@BNKonFOX) October 31, 2026
UCLA did its part with some style. The Bruins shut out the Nevada Wolf Pack 27-0, allowed 176 total yards and intercepted four passes to move to 8-0. Ohio State’s half of the prediction lost a fair amount of value by bedtime.
The Buckeyes are now 4-1 in the Big Ten, Indiana is 5-1, and Ohio State’s remaining league schedule includes the Northwestern Wildcats, Oregon, the Nebraska Cornhuskers and the Michigan Wolverines.
There is still a route. Ohio State owns the head-to-head win over Indiana, so winning out would probably be enough. With a freshman quarterback, winning out is a considerably taller order than it looked at breakfast.
Where we stand: Somewhat agree, UCLA has done everything required to be taken seriously, and its defense is the reason. The Ohio State half was the safe part of the pick on Saturday morning. By Sunday it had become the brave part.
4. Nick Saban, The Pat McAfee Show: Indiana will start dominating people
Saban made the case on Friday, the day before his 75th birthday on the College GameDay set in Bloomington.
“I think Indiana is going to start showing their true colors here and really start dominating people,” Saban said.
“I think Indiana has enough tools to be a really effective team on offense..
I think Josh Hoover is very capable and Coach Cignetti is great with quarterbacks” ~ Coach Saban
#PMSLive https://t.co/iYnUlCwX2G
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) October 30, 2026
Indiana did not dominate the Minnesota Golden Gophers. It survived them. The Hoosiers trailed 16-13 with 19 seconds left after a 60-yard Minnesota field goal, answered with a 60-yarder from Paddy McAteer, and won 23-16 in overtime when backup Grant Wilson hit Charlie Becker for a 25-yard touchdown on the first snap. Josh Hoover was pulled at halftime after his second interception of the season. It was Indiana’s second straight overtime game, and the special teams did not help, with two shanked punts, a blocked field goal and a botched snap on another kick.
Where we stand: Disagree, for now. To be fair to Saban, half of his argument was that nine straight weeks without a bye had worn Indiana down, and the bye finally arrives this Saturday. Ask me again after USC visits on Nov. 14.
5. Kirk Herbstreit, Nonstop: Indiana’s offense is not impressive
Herbstreit took the opposite view from his GameDay colleague on his podcast with Joey Galloway earlier in the week, after Indiana beat Michigan 13-6 in overtime without an offensive touchdown in regulation.
“I think it’s the totality of the offense. Watching them, I’m not overly impressed,” Herbstreit said.
Hoover was 8 of 19 for 119 yards before he was taken out, and Indiana’s first touchdown came on a two-play, 14-yard drive after the defense forced a fumble. Across two overtime games, the defending national champions have scored 36 points, so Saturday backed him up.
The defense remains the best thing about this team.
Where we stand: Agree. The defense is good enough to win most Saturdays on its own, and the offense is the reason Indiana keeps needing an extra period to do it. What Curt Cignetti decides at quarterback during the bye will tell us more than either of these two can.
6. Joel Klatt, The Joel Klatt Show: The Miami Hurricanes will be there in the end
Klatt moved Miami to No. 1 in his top 10 on Monday after a 52-23 win over the Pittsburgh Panthers.
“They destroyed Pitt 52-23. Darian Mensah threw for almost 400 yards and four touchdowns. Wide receiver Malachi Toney went crazy: 16 catches for 194 yards and three touchdowns. That’s a good football team, and I think they’re going to be there in the end. They certainly don’t have the toughest schedule of anybody.
“I can’t wait to see them play Notre Dame. If Notre Dame were to lose that game with already one loss on the docket, who knows? We’ll cross that bridge when we get there,” Klatt said.
Where we stand: Agree, with the reservation Klatt supplied himself. A 4-4 North Carolina team completing 82 percent of its passes is not what a national champion’s defense usually allows. The Notre Dame Fighting Irish are next, which is the first real chance to find out if Saturday was a bad night or a warning.
7. Joel Klatt, The Joel Klatt Show: The Big 12 is probably a one-bid league
Klatt said this on the same episode, after the BYU Cougars lost in double overtime at the UCF Knights and the Texas Tech Red Raiders lost at the Cincinnati Bearcats.
“Tech goes down, BYU goes down, and I think we’re back into this mode. It’s probably a one-bid league,” Klatt said.
Where we stand: Too early, and this week leaned against him. A one-loss Big 12 runner-up with a ranked win has a reasonable argument for an at-large spot. BYU visits Utah on Saturday, and the loser of that game is the team most likely to prove Klatt right.
8. Kirk Herbstreit, Nonstop: The Florida Gators had to beat Texas or the Georgia Bulldogs to be taken seriously
This one goes back to late September, after Florida’s 52-28 win over the Ole Miss Rebels, but Saturday finished the test. Galloway asked Herbstreit if the Gators needed one win out of Texas and Georgia.
“If you’re going where you want to go, you’ve got to be able to get one of those, for sure, to be evaluated as a team and to answer that question: Are they a national title or SEC championship contender? Yeah, you’d have to win one of those games,” Herbstreit said.
Where we stand: Agree with the test, and Florida passed the first half of it. The second half supplied the answer. Jon Sumrall has built a good team quickly, but it is not a title contender this season, and Saturday was not a close call.
9. Paul Finebaum, The Matt Barrie Show: The Auburn Tigers’ upset of Georgia was fluky
Finebaum said this on Oct. 25, a day after Auburn followed its 27-24 win in Athens by losing 38-17 at home to the LSU Tigers. He added that the bye week was the best thing that could have happened to Georgia.
“That always felt a little fluky to me, Matt. It always felt like Georgia was the team beat up that day and not coming off the bye,” Finebaum said.
Georgia, rested, did to Florida what the Bulldogs had failed to do to Auburn. Auburn, meanwhile, went to Oxford and lost 45-15 to Ole Miss, its second heavy defeat in the two games since it beat Georgia.
Where we stand: Agree. Two weeks later, the Auburn result looks more like the exception than the evidence. Georgia visits Ole Miss on Saturday, which will measure the Bulldogs rather better than Florida managed to.
10. Greg McElroy, Always College Football: Texas has the best two-loss resume in the country
McElroy made the case on his podcast after Texas beat Ole Miss.
“That’s three wins over teams that were ranked in the top 14 at kickoff. They have zero losses in those ranked games,” McElroy said.
Of all the two-loss teams in America, @GregMcElroy thinks @TexasFootball has the strongest résumé 💪
#HookEm 🤘 https://t.co/PJ32B9iSbi
— Always College Football (@AlwaysCFB) October 26, 2026
Texas held up its end on Saturday with a 31-3 win over the Mississippi State Bulldogs. The rest of the resume had a mixed evening. Ole Miss won by 30, which helps. Ohio State, the best win on the list, lost at USC. And Florida, which beat Texas in Austin, was handled by Georgia. The other loss came against the Oklahoma Sooners, and the win over the Tennessee Volunteers is unchanged after a Tennessee bye.
Where we stand: Still agree. The resume got slightly weaker on Saturday without Texas doing anything wrong, which is how November tends to treat everybody. The Missouri Tigers are next, and a third loss would end the conversation rather quickly.
We will be back next Sunday with 10 more, and we will keep checking on these. Riley, the Big 12 and Indiana’s offense should all have more to say for themselves by the time the leaves are gone.














Join the discussion
Be the first to join this discussion
Be respectful toward authors and fellow readers.
Sign in or create an account to join the conversation.
Report comment
Tell the moderation team why this comment may break the community guidelines.